Instagram has long been the cornerstone of influencer marketing, but 2025 tells a different story. Engagement rates have plummeted to their lowest levels in five years, averaging just 2.05% across all creator tiers. For brands and creators who've built their strategies around Instagram, this decline represents a fundamental shift in the social media landscape.
The Reality Check
Instagram's overall engagement rate per post dropped 16% in 2024 versus 2023. Meanwhile, TikTok continues to dominate with engagement rates five times higher than Instagram. The platform that once guaranteed reliable reach and interaction is now forcing creators and brands to completely rethink their strategies.
The Numbers Don't Lie
2.05%
Average Instagram engagement rate (5-year low)
-16%
Year-over-year engagement decline in 2024
0.95%
Engagement rate for 1M+ follower accounts
2.5%
TikTok's average engagement rate (5x higher)
Platform Comparison: Engagement by Influencer Tier
| Platform | Micro (10k-50k) | Mid-Tier (50k-500k) | Macro (500k-1M) | Celebrity (1M+) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11.7% ↑95% | 9.4% | 7.3% | 5.6% | |
| TikTok | ~15% | ~12% | ~10% | ~10% |
| YouTube | 1.9% | 2.5% | 3.5% | 3.4% |
Sources: The Cirqle, Influencer Marketing Hub, Statista. Instagram data shows recent rebound for adapted creators.
Why Engagement is Declining
The decline isn't random—it's the result of multiple converging factors. Understanding these causes is crucial for developing effective counter-strategies.
Algorithm Overhaul
Instagram quietly overhauled its ranking algorithm in spring 2025, prioritizing AI prediction models and favoring original content with strong 3-second retention over traditional vanity metrics like likes.
Key Changes:
User Behavior Shifts
Users are becoming "silent viewers" and "doom scrollers," consuming content passively without engaging. Interactions have moved to private DMs and Stories rather than public likes and comments.
Behavioral Changes:
Content Saturation & Competition
With over 50 million creators worldwide and TikTok capturing significant user attention, Instagram faces unprecedented competition for engagement. Content fatigue is real.
Market Reality:
Proven Strategies to Fight Back
The decline isn't permanent—creators who adapt are seeing remarkable recoveries. Here are the strategies that are working in 2025.
Prioritize High-Engagement Formats
Generate highest engagement rates of any post type
Multi-image posts encourage swiping and longer engagement
Use polls, questions, and quizzes to boost engagement
Optimize for Algorithm Signals
Front-load your best content to stop the scroll
Create valuable content worth bookmarking
Leverage popular sounds for algorithm boost
Diversify Platforms
Leverage superior engagement rates
Tap into Google's massive reach
Drive engaged followers between platforms
Focus on Niche Appeal
Specialized content drives deeper engagement
Foster loyal followers who actively engage
Better to have 10K engaged than 100K passive
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Instagram engagement declining in 2025?
Instagram engagement is declining due to algorithm changes prioritizing Reels and retention metrics, user behavior shifts toward passive consumption, content saturation, and competition from TikTok. The platform now averages 2.05% engagement, down from previous years.
How does Instagram engagement compare to TikTok in 2025?
TikTok significantly outperforms Instagram with average engagement rates of 2.5% compared to Instagram's 0.5%. TikTok influencers with over 1 million followers average 10%+ engagement, while Instagram influencers of the same size see under 1%.
Are micro-influencers affected by Instagram's engagement decline?
Micro-influencers are more resilient but still affected. While they maintain higher engagement rates than macro-influencers (around 11.7% in some studies), they've experienced inconsistent reach and Story view drops due to algorithm changes.
What content formats perform best on Instagram in 2025?
Reels generate the highest engagement rates, followed by carousel posts and interactive Stories. The algorithm prioritizes video content with strong hooks in the first 1-2 seconds and content that generates saves and shares.
How can creators combat declining Instagram engagement?
Focus on Reels and carousel posts, increase interactivity with polls and questions, optimize for early hooks and retention, diversify to TikTok and YouTube, leverage niche appeal, and continuously analyze performance data to adapt strategies.
Related Resources
Choosing the Right Influencer
Learn how to vet creators by reach, engagement, brand fit, and audience alignment.
Read Guide →Micro vs Macro Influencers
Understand the differences and decide which tier works best for your campaigns.
Compare Options →